Florida Homeowners Guide · Myths vs. Facts

Florida homeowners insurance myths that cost people money

Most insurance surprises come from an assumption that sounded reasonable. These are the ones our advisors correct most often, with what is actually true in Florida and where to read more.

Prefer to talk? Call (954) 475-8886

Written and reviewed by licensed Florida insurance advisors at Allied Insurance Group · Updated October 2026

4.8★★★★★Google Rating · 750+ Reviews

Since 2006 · serving Florida homeowners

Independent · agency, not tied to one insurer

Multiple · A-rated carriers

Licensed · Florida advisors

4.8 ★ · Google rating · 750+ reviews

Executive summary

The short version

The costliest myths in Florida are that homeowners insurance covers flood (it does not), that the hurricane deductible is a percentage of the damage (it is a percentage of your dwelling limit), and that Citizens is a cheap permanent option (it is a last resort with eligibility rules and surcharge risk).

Close behind are assumptions about roofs, slow leaks and how much coverage a home needs. Each myth below has a short correction and a link to the full guide.

  • Flood, including storm surge, is never part of a homeowners policy.
  • A 2% hurricane deductible means 2% of the dwelling limit, not 2% of the loss.
  • Roof age alone cannot disqualify a roof under 15 years old.
  • Insure for the cost to rebuild, not the market value.
  • The cheapest quote is often the one with the least coverage.

Myths about what is covered

Short answer: Flood, slow leaks, mold and wear and tear are the exclusions people most often assume are covered.

Myth Fact Read more
My homeowners policy covers flood. Flood and storm surge are excluded. They require a separate flood policy. Flood guide
I am not in a flood zone, so I cannot flood. Lower-risk zones still flood. The zone decides whether a lender requires coverage, not whether water can reach you. Flood guide
All water damage is covered. Sudden and accidental leaks usually are. Slow leaks, seepage and neglected maintenance usually are not. Water damage guide
Insurance will replace my old roof. Insurance covers sudden damage from a covered cause, not a roof that has worn out. Roof age guide
Mold is always covered. Usually only when it follows a covered water loss, and often up to a sub-limit. Water damage guide

Myths about hurricanes and deductibles

Short answer: The hurricane deductible is based on your coverage amount, applies only to declared hurricanes and cannot be changed when a storm is on the way.

Myth Fact Read more
A 2% deductible means I pay 2% of the damage. It is 2% of your dwelling limit. On a $400,000 limit that is $8,000. Hurricane deductible guide
The hurricane deductible applies to any big storm. Only to a storm declared a hurricane by the National Hurricane Center, within a defined window. Hurricane deductible guide
I will buy or change coverage when a storm is forecast. Insurers suspend new policies and changes once a watch or warning is issued, and NFIP flood policies usually have a 30-day wait. Storm checklist
FEMA will make me whole after a disaster. Federal disaster assistance is limited and often comes as a loan. It is not a substitute for insurance. Flood guide
Illustration: 2% of the damage vs. 2% of the dwelling limit

What people expect: 2% of a $30,000 loss$600
What applies: 2% of a $400,000 dwelling limit$8,000

Example arithmetic. Your deductible appears as a dollar amount on your declarations page.

Myths about roofs and inspections

Short answer: Roof age alone has legal limits as a reason for refusal, a four-point inspection is not a full home inspection, and wind mitigation reports expire.

Myth Fact Read more
Insurers can drop anyone with a roof over 10 years old. An insurer may not refuse to issue or renew solely for age if the roof is under 15 years old, and older roofs get the right to an inspection. Roof age guide
A roof repair makes my roof new for insurance. Roof age is measured from the last full replacement, not from repairs. Roof age guide
A four-point inspection is the same as a home inspection. It covers only the roof, electrical, plumbing and HVAC, for the insurer’s purposes. Four-point guide
Wind mitigation inspections are only for new homes. Any home can have one, and older homes with upgrades often benefit most. Reports are generally valid for five years. Wind mitigation guide

Myths about price and coverage amounts

Short answer: Coverage should match the cost to rebuild, and a lower premium usually reflects a difference in coverage.

What is true

  • Dwelling coverage is based on rebuilding cost
  • The mortgage balance is the lender’s minimum, not your target
  • Comparing quotes means matching limits, deductibles and endorsements
  • Independent agents can compare several carriers at once
What is not

  • Insure the home for its market value
  • Insure only what you owe the bank
  • The cheapest quote is the best deal
  • All policies are basically the same

Market value includes the land and the neighborhood. Insurance pays to rebuild the structure at current labor and material prices, which can be higher or lower than what the home would sell for. Our Florida homeowners insurance guide lists what to compare line by line.

Myths about Citizens

Short answer: Citizens is the insurer of last resort. It has eligibility rules, a flood requirement and surcharge risk.

Myth Fact
Anyone can choose Citizens. You generally qualify only if no private insurer offers coverage, or private offers are more than 20% above the Citizens premium.
Once I am in Citizens I can stay. A private takeout offer within 20% of your Citizens renewal premium generally ends your eligibility.
Citizens is always cheapest. Not by design, and its policyholders can be surcharged up to 15% of premium if Citizens runs a deficit.
Citizens does not care about flood. Citizens policies that include wind must carry flood insurance, with the final phase effective January 1, 2027.

The full rules are in our Citizens guide.

Myths about claims

Short answer: Deadlines are shorter than many people think, and small claims are not free.

  • Myth: I have years to file. Florida generally requires notice of a property claim within 1 year of the date of loss.
  • Myth: Every claim is worth filing. A claim near or below the deductible may pay nothing and still appear in your history.
  • Myth: I should wait for the adjuster before touching anything. You are expected to prevent further damage. Photograph first, then tarp and dry.
  • Myth: My agent decides my claim. The insurer’s adjusters decide. Your agent helps you report, understand and follow up.

See the Florida claims guide for the full timeline.

How to check your own policy in ten minutes

Short answer: Pull out your declarations page and endorsement list and look for seven things.

  • Dwelling limit: does it reflect today’s rebuilding cost?
  • Hurricane deductible, in dollars
  • All-other-perils deductible
  • Roof settlement: replacement cost, actual cash value or schedule
  • Any water damage limit or exclusion
  • Ordinance or law percentage
  • Whether you have a separate flood policy

If any answer surprises you, send the page to us for a policy review.

Questions Florida homeowners ask us

Frequently asked questions

No. Flood is excluded and requires a separate policy through the NFIP or a private flood insurer.

Wind damage from a hurricane is covered, subject to the hurricane deductible. Storm surge and rising water are flood and are not.

No. A percentage hurricane deductible is a percentage of your dwelling coverage limit.

It is not federally required, but homes in lower-risk zones do flood. Consider your location, elevation and ability to absorb the loss.

Not solely for age. Florida law bars refusing to issue or renew solely because of roof age when the roof is under 15 years old.

Not guaranteed, but it commonly opens more carriers and can earn credits once a new wind mitigation report is submitted.

No. Insure it for the estimated cost to rebuild, which excludes land value and reflects current construction costs.

Only if the coverage is the same. Lower premiums often come from higher deductibles, actual cash value roof coverage or water damage limits.

Sometimes its premium is lower, but it is designed as a last resort, has eligibility rules and carries surcharge risk.

No. Eligibility is re-tested, and a takeout offer within 20 percent of your renewal premium generally means you cannot stay.

Usually only when mold results from a covered water loss, and often up to a limited amount.

Generally no. Seepage over a period of weeks is a standard exclusion.

Only if you have ordinance or law coverage, typically offered at 25 or 50 percent of the dwelling limit.

Only up to a low sub-limit for theft on most policies. Valuable items should be scheduled.

Only in a very limited way. Business property and liability usually need an endorsement or a separate policy.

No. Insect and vermin damage is excluded as a maintenance issue.

Florida policies cover catastrophic ground cover collapse as defined by law. Broader sinkhole coverage is optional and not always available.

Insurers suspend binding new policies and changes when a tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is issued, so do not wait.

Not always, but claims history is an underwriting factor and can affect premium or eligibility.

No. A captive agent represents one company. An independent agency like Allied compares multiple carriers.

Often yes, particularly if the roof has been replaced or the home has shutters or impact windows.

Send us your declarations page for a policy review. A licensed advisor will explain it in plain language.

Keep reading

Related Florida homeowners guides

Florida Homeowners Insurance GuideFlorida Homeowners Insurance GuideHow coverage, pricing and underwriting work in Florida.Florida Flood Insurance GuideFlorida Flood Insurance GuideWhy home policies exclude flood and how to cover it.Hurricane Deductibles GuideHurricane Deductibles GuideHow the deductible works, plus a storm-season checklist.Citizens Insurance in FloridaCitizens Insurance in FloridaEligibility, the 20% rule, takeouts and flood requirements.

Looking for something else? Visit the Allied Answer Desk, browse Florida insurance by city, or go back to the Florida Homeowners Insurance Guide.

Why homeowners trust Allied

Independent, local and here after the sale.

Serving Florida since 2006Two decades helping Florida homeowners through hard and soft insurance markets.
Independent agencyWe work for you, not for one insurance company, and compare options side by side.
Multiple A-rated carriersAccess to multiple A-rated carriers, so one company’s rules do not decide your options.
Local expertiseBased in Hollywood, Florida. We work in the same market our clients live in.
Licensed advisorsYour questions are answered by licensed Florida insurance advisors.
4.8 on Google, 750+ reviewsRead what Florida homeowners say about working with us. See our reviews
★★★★★“Yunior was an exceptional agent. He showed me 3 different plans and guided me through the whole process.”Jubani Millares · Google
★★★★★“Cristina was very attentive and responded back to me quickly with my home insurance issue. Thank you so much.”Jose Diaz · Google
★★★★★“Ron is such a caring and understanding agent. He truly goes above and beyond for his clients.”Lovely Katherine · Google

Read more Google reviews · See the carriers we work with

Not sure which of these applies to your policy? Let us check.

Send us your declarations page. A licensed Allied advisor will explain what you have, what is missing and what your options are.

Or call (954) 475-8886

This guide is general information for Florida homeowners, not legal advice and not a statement of coverage. Coverage, eligibility, deductibles and pricing depend on the insurer, the policy form and your property. Laws, Citizens rules and carrier guidelines change; confirm current details with a licensed advisor and read your policy. Allied Insurance Group, 6600 Taft Street #100, Hollywood, FL 33024 · (954) 475-8886.

CallGet My Home Quote